Our Smartphone Stores.  Buy Accessories For Your... Blackberry Android Moto Q iPhone Centro Treo



Treo Case | Reopening the Treo 650 Case

Since my last big case of Treo cases back in May I’ve continued to keep a watchful eye on new products and so after collecting an additional number of Treo cases from our Treo Accessory Shop  I decided that this might be a good time to reopen the case (all puns intended…).

To quickly recap, the three cases that I’ve now latched on to for good are:

  1. Seidio’s vertical Shield Holster which continues to be my favourite for its simplicity and protection with my Treo screen facing inwards and the only one that I can use easily to listen to music while mobile at work, home or outside.
  2. The Foofpod fabric case wich is pretty much always the funky alternative to Seidio’s when I’m wearing a suit, jacket or coat.
  3. Covertec’s Horizontal Pouch Case is my preferred ‘elegant’  (but not luxury) case for those occasions where Seidio’s plastic case just won’t do.

So, let’s see if any of the new cases that I have on hand might make it to my personal collection…

Nutshell Natural Leather Case $54.95 (Top Loading Pouch Case)
I had been curious about the Nutshell case for a while as the pictures that I had seen conveyed the image of a very high quality leather case.

Upon inspection I certainly wasn’t disappointed.  The leather is indeed very thick yet smooth and feels great in your hands.  The inside is lined with a fine soft black suede which caresses your Treo and makes it easy to insert and remove once on your waist (but not easy enough that it might fall out).  Lacking in Nutshell’s case is a headset jack cut-out which means that you won’t be able to listen to your music.

Additionally, the industrial strength steel belt clip is so strong that it takes a little effort to actually attach it to your belt and once it’s on there’s pretty much zero chance that it would accidentally fall off.  However, be prepared to leave some scratches on the inside of your belt – something which you’ll probably want to avoid if like me you have a reversible belt.  Also, the belt clip is completely fixed and does not have a rotating mechanism which Treonauts used to driving with their case attached may find bothersome.

It’s hard to dismiss Nutshell’s case as it is truly extremely well built but in my case the slight scratch issue on the belt and the lack of a rotating clip make it a no go for me.  Nevertheless, I am very tempted to go for the version without the clip (next on my list to try) as it really provides a very snug fit and protection for my Treo.

Smartphone Experts P6 Pouch Case $19.95 (Side Loading Pouch Case)
While it’s one of the most economical cases available, the P6 case is nonetheless extremely well built with a good quality leather exterior and soft velvet interior.

Supported by two very strong front magnets, the leather flaps closes shut and stays shut without any risk for your Treo to take an unwanted exit.  The leather covered belt clip is also robust and grips strongly to your belt without risking any scratches.  Also, although the belt clip does not rotate the vertical case is much less prone to be in the way sitting down while driving.


There’s very little not to like about the P6 case.  It’s practical, cost effective, has a slim form factor and great build quality.  I would definitely consider it if I didn’t already have the Covertec.

Mobo Wallet Organizer Case $34.95 (Top Loading Pouch Case)
Currently the only Treo case that I know of that also holds up to four of your credit cards, Mobo’s Wallet Organizer is an interesting but somewhat bulky, unrefined and ultimately fairly useless first attempt.

The overall build quality is good with a magnetic leather flap over the top loading section.  However, whereas other cases allow you to insert your Treo with the screen facing inwards or outwards this one can only be used outwards which means that you’ll need to (somewhat awkwardly) rotate the Treo in your hand every time you remove it to answer a call.

As you will notice in the picture, holding four credit cards is evidently too much and notwithstanding the fact that adds another 1/4” the velcro strap barely closes once you have done this.  Furthermore, the rotating belt clip is OK but for the metal end which will again likely scratch your belt and it also does not provide a tight grip unless you’re wearing a thick belt.

I won’t be adding this Wallet Organizer case to my collection anytime soon.

Vaja PA31/32 Flip Top Case $74.95
Like its other more popular T65 case, Vaja pride themselves in the high craftsmanship of their products with excellent quality leathers used throughout.

However, the company still has a little way to go is in the area of “form follows function” as with the T65 case the borders of the leather case surrounding the keyboard are too high and therefore provide cumbersome access for typing.

Leaving this aside, the case (no clip on mine) as always makes a splash of elegance.  Cut-outs at the bottom provide easy access to the headset jack and I was able to fit and charge the Treo in this case on Seidio’s INNODock cradle as well as the retractable S&C cable without any problems.

There are also two convenient slots for SD Cards and another larger slot under these that could accomodate a few business cards or a credit card.  The closing flap however is a push button instead of a magnet which makes it just that little bit more annoying to close.

If Vaja could sort out the issue of the high leather borders around the keyboard I would most likely again switch to using one.  In the meantime however I want a case that not only looks good but that also serves its function well.

Smartphone Experts S650 Skin Case
Skin cases appear to be growing in popularity and I hadn’t tried one since the days of my Treo 600.  At the time I wasn’t too impressed because I found the rubber material to be a magnet for dirt and for me at least not a terribly elegant solution.

Although this is still not the case for me, the latest incarnation for the Treo 650 has nonetheless left me fairly impressed.  The quality of the material, build as well as the parts covered and cut out have all much improved.  Leaving aside the open screen and keyboard this skin case provide an almost hermetic protection against scratches for your Treo.

Additionally, although not perfect, access to the covered navigation keys and keyboard are surprisingly easy with this thin (about 2mm) latex envelope.  It may not be for me, it may not be pretty but overall it works and this type of case will undoubtedly appeal to a particular audience.

Conclusion
My top votes in this roundup must go to the Smartphone Experts P6 Pouch Case and Nutshell Natural Leather Case (albeit ideally a version without the clip) – both of which I could envisage adding to my collection.

I’m curious about your own choice of cases…

Treo 650 Case Opened
1. Do you have a case for your Treo?

Yes
No

2. What type of case do you have for your Treo? (Check all that apply)

Form-Fit Case Holster
Flip-Lid Case Hard Case
Pouch Case Skin Case
Wallet Case Fabric Case

Click Here to View Current Results

Treonauts never rest their case


Posted by Andrew on July 20, 2005 at 03:21 PM

Treo Accessories , Treo Case

| Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c71a953ef00d8348398d869e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Treo Case | Reopening the Treo 650 Case:



Comments

1
by Paul Williamson | Jul 20, 2005 5:54:08 PM

Re Nutshell Case - I have been using one for 3 months - 2 points - mine does have an earphone cutout so listening to music etc is no problem and the clip is a firm connection but has a reasonable range of slide and rotate so I find that it naturally moves to the best position eg when putting on a seat belt etc. i also chose the paua (abalone) insert and am very pleased - really classy.

2
by Paul Biba | Jul 20, 2005 8:19:55 PM

You need to get the Treo-specific Nutshell case. Mine has cutouts for the earphone and the charge cable. This is the fourth Nutshell case I've owned and I've loved them all. I don't wear a belt, suspenders only, and Nutshell has the only clip I've found that is secure when just attached to my pants waistband.

3
by Jimbo | Jul 21, 2005 10:20:54 PM

I'd love to know what you think of the B650 Book Case:
http://store.treonauts.com/content/accessories/4-22--134.htm

4
by msales15 | Jul 22, 2005 5:49:22 PM

The "case" review is great. I have been using the P6 with a "skinned 650" for since may. GREAT CASE!!!! It is however a "top loading pouch, not side loading.

5
by Orion | Jul 22, 2005 8:16:40 PM

Great post Andrew! A case is a 'must have' for any Treo owner. How could anyone leave a major investment unprotected?

As a first time owner, I read all the Treo sites looking for the perfect solution for my specific needs. After reading your post regarding the Covertec horizontal case I ordered one online. I can't wait to get it!

Orion

6
by Dave | Jul 23, 2005 7:38:19 AM

I have a nutshell pouch with no belt clip, and the 'tab' top. I've had it for a year or so, and it's excellent. I looked at reviews for lots of cases and the nutshell is simple, effective and incredibly well made for the cost. I would buy another in a heartbeat. Mine didn't have a headphone cutout, but it is the work of seconds for a leather worker to punch it out for you. The bottom is soft enough to 'feel' the position. I marked it with a biro and then punched it with a circular punch used for cutting gaskets.

Dave

7
by peter | Jul 25, 2005 1:32:02 AM

Timbuk2 has just released a holster for the Treo 650 (available from their web site- $25)
I like it, but it offers no real protection for the screen, which faces out.
On the plus side, It comes in great colors and attaches to belt or shoulder strap.

8
by Erika | Jul 29, 2005 11:14:45 AM

This site is awesome for a new Treo user such as myself. What a wealth of information! Why i'm posting is because I'd like to let everyone in on the cases of all cases as far as I am concenred. The STM iPod Cocoon. This site gave me the idea for it, as it stated that the original iPod case would fit the Treo in it, due to its similiar dimensions.

see here:
http://www.standardtm.com.au/ipodcocoon

This STM case is excellent. There is a net inside that holds the Treo, screen side in against the soft material and then it zips up tightly so that just the attenna and the silence switch are visible. Can't really access the headphone port easily, but it is possible to stuff a headset through the slot at the bottom, originally intended for ipod cables. The case is rock-hard, and includes a good belt clip that has never slipped off. True, it's not totally easy to get to the Treo during a phone call, because you have to unzip then take out the phone, however, you can do it, and i've never missed a call because it took so long to get the phone out.

I've had my treo for about a month, and I usually scratch and ruin everything within that time, but because of this case my treo remains as nice as it was the day i bought it. Check it out!

9
by Derek Woolverton | Aug 10, 2005 3:37:05 AM

I got a smartphone experts skin case about eight months ago, and it had far more styling back then then it seems to have now. (You can finally see my comparison between it and the boxwave here: http://dwoolstar.blogspot.com/2005/08/treo-650-skin-case-smackdown-boxwave.html )

I wonder why they changed the mold. I though the older design was rather good.

10
by Derek | Aug 10, 2005 7:32:57 PM

Ah, I messed up. The case I actually like (and have) is the JAVOedge. I've updated my smackdown. Thanks to Treonauts for the pictures of the S650 that helped me figure out that's not what I had.

11
by monica | Apr 1, 2006 2:00:45 PM

can somebody answer me this! do the magnets on the phone cases damage the phone in any way ?

The comments to this entry are closed.

 
Footer graphic
©2006 Treonauts.com | Subscribe to the Treonauts Blog RSS Feed

Treonauts

Treo Blog
Treo Forum
Treo Accessories Store
Treo Software Store

iPhoniacs

iPhone Blog
iPhone Accessories Guide
iPhone Accessories Store
iPhone Software Store

Centronauts

Centro Forum
Centro Accessories Guide
Centro Accessories Store
Centro Software Store