Treo 680 Battery: Review Part 7
[Update: The original spare Palm 1200mAh battery for your Treo 680 and forthcoming Treo 750 is finally available in the Treonauts Accessories Shop.
Update2: You can now also have a 2400mAh Treo 680 Extended Battery and Treo 750 Extended Battery.]
As most Treonauts will undoubtedly already know, the new Treo 680 has the rather pleasing benefit and distinct advantage of being the lightest and slimmest PalmOS Treo smartphone to have been released to date (see Treo 680 Review Part 2: Form-Factor Design).
Evidently, one of the most important reasons why the Treo 680 was able to slim down is the fact that Palm has used a 6mm thick 1200mAh battery instead of the 10mm thick 1800mAh standard Treo battery found on the 650 and 700p – a 4mm difference.
Comparing both batteries you will immediately be able to calculate that the 1800mAh has 50% more capacity than the 1200mAh or looked at another way the 1200mAh has 33% less capacity than the 1800mAh one. Therefore, if we know that the standard 1800mAh Treo 650 battery had a ‘Talk Time’ performance of 5 to 6 hours (300 to 360 minutes) we would have to assume that the 1200mAh battery found on the Treo 680 has a talk time performance of between 3 hours 20 minutes and 4 hours (200 to 240 minutes) – or again 33% less than the 1800mAh.
Palm’s official Treo 680 Talk and Standby times (see Treo 680 Comparison Chart) lists 4 hours and 300 hours (12.5 days) respectively – well within range of the above calculations. Over the past week however some Treonauts have complained that they are unable to achieve these rated times and finding that they are having large drops in battery life with minimal usage. I therefore decided to take a much closer look at the overall Treo 680 battery performance – a rather long, meticulous and painstaking process as you will be able to appreciate below.
Please Note: Although I have now had the opportunity to perform multiple battery tests I am neither an electrical engineer nor do I benefit from any sort of professional measuring equipment. Thus, any results should be considered as those of just _one_ user and not necessarily indicative of those that others might experience. Additionally, it should also be noted that there are dozens of settings which can influence your individual battery life (such as Bluetooth, screen brightness, etc.) and therefore battery performance will vary greatly between users (for example my screen brightness is always set to maximum to the detriment of greater battery life).
Treo 680 Battery Tests
1. Discharge Tests
The first test that I performed was a ‘Discharge Test’ using an application called Battery TIME. As the name of the application suggests, this free utility allows me to get the exact “Elapsed Time” with the screen ‘always on’ between a 100% fully charged Treo battery until it reaches 10% capacity. After this I can easily extrapolate what the full 100% time would be.
I tested using Battery TIME on a Palm Treo 680 Unlocked with a standard 1200mAh battery under the following conditions:
- Phone Radio OFF (1) and ON (2)
- Bluetooth OFF
- Screen Brightness MAX
- Infrared ON
The results are shown here on the right and as you can appreciate a Treo 680 battery used with the screen ‘Always On’ at maximum brightness (a highly unlikely occurrence under normal usage) still achieved a very respectable 4 hours 17minutes with the Radio ON.
Next I tested again using Battery TIME on a Palm Treo 680 Unlocked but this time using an 1800mAh battery from my old Treo 650 under exactly the same conditions as above (however because of time constraints only testing with the Phone OFF).
The results here on the right are meaningful and interesting on two fronts. The first is that since the 1800mAh battery is 50% larger than the previous test I was expecting to see a “100% Battery Usage” time of some 6.5 hours (4.17 hours + 50%) but instead I got a result of nearly 7 hours here.
It thus appears that the standard 1200mAh battery on the Treo 680 has a different mAh/minute consumption (4.68) compared to the 1800mAh battery which comes in at 4.30 – but this 10% variance is not meaningful. According to this test, if the 1200mAh battery had the same mAh/min consumption as the 1800mAh battery then we should have a 100% Battery Usage of 279mins instead of the current 257mins performance – again 22mins difference is not necessarily meaningful though without running full and repeated battery tests.
Having said this, as I mentioned before I am no electrical engineer nor a battery expert but this test would seem to suggest that for the standard Treo 680 battery (but not the Treo itself) is just mildly less efficient than the previous larger capacity standard Treo 650 battery. In all fairness this may simply be due to the different circuitry found on the 1200mAh battery and is certainly in no way indicative of any sort of defect.
2. Talk Time Test
Possibly the most important test for most Treonauts will relate to the Talk Time performance. For this test I first fully charged my Treo 680 battery (the light at the top left corner of the smartphone turns solid green), then placed a call to my home number and monitored the time elapsed until the battery completely died and my Treo switched off (settings were: BT OFF + Infrared ON). (Please also note that as in any normal Treo call the screen automatically dimmed to Level 1 brightness where it stayed for the entire duration of the call).
Evidently, above all, I wanted to ensure that my Treo 680 would at the very least match Palm’s official rated 4hours of talk time and on this front I’m very glad to report that it did. The screenshot here on the right clearly shows that my call duration has been 4hours and that I still have 33% battery power remaining.
Independent of any issues that some Treonauts might feel they are having with their Treo 680 this clearly shows that Palm has not been in any way misleading about its talk time performance.
Unfortunately because of a technical error on my part you will have to wait for an update tomorrow so that I can let you know exactly just how much longer the call lasted beyond 4hours since I was unable to get the Call Duration data from my Call Log…
Treo 680 Battery Optimization Tips
As I mentioned earlier every Treonaut will have a slightly different battery performance on his or her Treo 680 – quite normal given that everyone will have different settings and usage patterns. Havind said this, below are a few basic tips to help you modify some of the settings on your Treo to optimize battery performance:
Go to Prefs > Power and:
- Turn “Beam Receive” OFF
- Set “Auto-off after” a 15 seconds
- Set your “Screen Brightness” to a medium setting (3 or 4 clicks under MAX or even less)
- Set “Dim backlight after” to 30 seconds
Other settings:
- Turn Bluetooth OFF if/when you are not using a wireless headset or other BT device
- Turn “Select Network” to MANUAL instead of Automatic (go to Phone > Options > Select Network and click on your carrier)
- UPDATE: Go to Prefs > Date & Time > Set “Automatically set” to “Nothing” (this makes a very significant difference in power usage – thanks for the tip Casey.)
- Disable “Active Polling” in Versamail or other 3rd party email solution
- You can use a software utility called KB LightsOff to turn off the keyboard lights of your Treo when they are not needed
- Also Phone Technician which will completely turn off your screen during a call to save even more battery life.
Conclusion
It’s a fact that I could be running battery tests for an entire year and likely get slightly different results every time. Having said this, for me the most important thing running these tests has been to ensure that the official Treo 680 power ratings are correct – thankfully they were all well within range.
Evidently, Treo 650 owners (particularly those that have been used to an extended battery) who recently upgraded to the 680 will likely be the ones to complain most vociferously about the new battery performance. However they will have to remember that this is one of the compromises that they will need to make in order to benefit from the new lighter and slimmer form-factor of the Treo 680.
At the same time, both a spare original spare Palm 1200mAh battery and 2400mAh Treo 680 Extended Battery should soon become available giving Treonauts more power options. In the meantime, regularly charging your Treo overnight and during the day depending on your usage will be a pretty simple and effective way to always keep your Treo fully powered.
Treonauts are always extremely meticulous… 
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c71a953ef00d83454e10569e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Treo 680 Battery: Review Part 7:
Comments
I have confirmed personally that turning off the time sync. saves gobs of battery life. Yesterday with time sync on I was down to 10% battery life by 1pm. Today with time sync off my battery is at 72% at noon. This is with chatter email (push) on.
What's weird is that even if you turn the phone off completely, the battery life is still really lousy. My 650 has been sitting around for 4 days and its battery is still at half charge. The 680 sits overnight with the phone off and loses 20%.
I just bought the Treo 680 and am looking for a source for the grafitti software that Palm omitted to install.
Thanks everyone re 680 battery tips - I followed some of the suggestions and turned off a few features and my battery life has definitely improved! Still not as great as the 650, but enough to make it through the day.
I had to return mine. I had two problems.
1) A bit of a lag every once-in-a-while (pressing a key would not yield anything for a few seconds)
2) Battery lasted 1.5 days in standby
I'll wait a few months then try it again.
Do you know if the extended battery covers will come in colors to match the phones? I have Crimson and wouldn't want a Graphite battery cover.
I just got my graphite unlocked treo 680 7 days ago.
It's fully charged at 7pm. No activity since but at 6am (that's just 11 hours of standby time), I couldn't even make a call because the battery needs to be charged again.
I turned of the bt and adj the brightness to almost dark the following night and tried the same test, still the battery needs to be charged again at 9am (14 hrs of standby time).
I called Palm and they will replace my unit because it is very unsual for my fully charged battery to get drained overnight w/ out activity.....Yes, the whole unit......
I have just upgraded from the treo 600 to the 680....after about 50 hard resets I got almost all my data transfered....ohh and if you use subfolders in outlook contacts...use keysuite or a 3rd party to hotsync! Anyway has anyone gotten AIM to work on the 680. Every time I try it disables my bt and deletes files causing the 50+ hard reset.
Now on my second treo 680, the last one kept having jarbled symbols where the service provider name should be, then if i tried to re-set it or take the battery out, it would just say ''network search'' for at least an hour, not letting me make or receive calls. hopefully this time around will be better.
Got a 650 personally (which I like a lot), and bought a 680 for my wife.
Without actually making a single phone call (the phone is switched on of course), and with all 'optimizations' done, she gets 40 hours of standby time.
This is really unacceptable. It means she has to recharge every night. 40h if a far cry from the official 300h. I can accept 150h, but less than 48h!
Come on Palm, you can do better than this !
There's been a big discussion on battery problems. How many of you actually calibrated the battery when you first got it? (like you're supposed to do for ALL lithium batteries not just treo batteries) Lithium batteries, are to be calibrated first before it functions at its full capacity. Brand new litjiums require 2-3 full discharges. Remember you must FULLY discharge to the point where you can't even turn your treo on and you must fully charge inbetween the discharges. You also should do a full drain (not twice like you do when you geta new lithium battery) once a month to maintain the full compacity of the battery. Trust me this will solve your major drain issues AND extend the life of your battery. Like you my battery drained 80-90% the first night. and just made it thru the first day. I'm a moderate user, (not a business user) using email, browsing the web and talking. Now, after clibration, I easily get 2-1/2 days before I need to charge again, 3 days if it's used lighter than I normally use. My settings are as follows: Screen brighteness 1 click under medium, Beam off, bluetooth off, auto-off 1min, and dim screen after 30 seconds on phone. Once my battey has been calibrated I've always charged my phonesevery night and I do perform a monthly calibration. It's amazing how much more of life you get out of these batteries. It always disappoints me when I see the batteries go before their time simply because the calibrations were never done.
Also, for clarification stand by time is with the phone off and the battery not being used. Hope this helps and clarify things for many of you.
I have no complaints. I get about the same results with my battery and my phone using the same technique.
The hard part was charging the battery fully when I first got the phone instead of playing with it. But, it does provide you with better performance.
With moderate use, a few phone calls a day, automatic e-mail checking ot my pop3 server, and just about the same settings as JC, I can get about 2 days. I prefer to charge everynight though because I prefer to have a full charge for the day no matter how long the phone is supposed to last. I'll probably get a second battery too.
For me the battery is not a big issue because I can always find a way to charge my phone whether at home, at work, or on the road. My concern is the reliability of the phone and so far the 680 is awesome. I don't even think I've had to reset it yet.
Are KB Light Off and Phone Technician compatible with the 680?
I purchased a Treo 680 one week ago and I returned it today, disappointed by the short battery life (even after applying all the tweaks suggested here). The Cingular tech told me I was not the first to return a Treo 680 for this reason.
For seven days I fully charged the 680 each night and with little to no use the battery would drain to unusability by mid evening of the next day. Today when I went back to my dependable Treo 650, it still showed 20% power after sitting in a drawer for a week. The 650 just looks and feels better built to me. It also lasts for the duration of a weekend trip.
Others have commented on some of the strange changes noticed in the 680's software, but I wonder why the Blazer web browser in the 680 no longer contained a "disconnect" menu command?
-SRE
Thank you, Casey Carter!
I was determined to stay with my 680 due to speed and feel, but, having used the 650 since release, the VERY short battery life on standby was looming as a serious inconvenience. I could not make it through the day on a charge.
Turned off the "automatic" date/time setting and now have a full day's charge in one battery.
Previously, was convinced that the time was less than 1/4 of that of the 650 with the 1800 battery. Now, it's somewhere between 1/2 and 2/3, which is quite livable until the extended battery comes out.
The drain created by the automatic date/time setting should be widely documented...I suspect quite a few returns would not be made if this were known.
HH
Hi
I am also having a frustrating time with my TREO 680 battery (dead after about 12 hours of light use). I am trying the various tips, but how do you turn GPRS off? Is it a matter of simply selecting GSM instead of GPRS network in preferences? Also, I have not turned email on yet, but maybe it is automatically on. How do you turn email off? I am using the standard email software (versamail) that came with the phone.
Also, I am ashamed to say I didnt do the battery calibration thing - I didnt realise that was still a requirement for Li batteries, and the instructions didnt mention it, but anyway, is it too late to do this after you have used the phone for a couple of days?
Thanks for any advice.
DG
I did the battery calibration thing - and everything else suggested - and am still losing almost all power overnight, after a full charge, with the phone turned off. So - I've returned my phone and purchased a 650 instead. The Cingular salesperson did say that it's probably some sort of software glitch, causing some type of software to keep cycling and drawing out all the power - and sooner or later, there will be a recall. I just can't live with minimal battery, such as DG talks about above, so - good by slim phone, hello 650, which is hopefully pretty darned good.
Anne
UPDATE.
I calibrated my battery (2 discharge/recharge cycles), turned off the various things mentioned above (time checking, GPRS, bluetooth etc), and 1.5 hours after turning it on, I am still at 99% battery capacity with the phone ON. Obviously it is still very early to be boasting about my new results, but this is a BIG improvement over the performance of my phone yesterday (roughly 8% per hour) and it should translate to at least 4-5 days of standby time with phone on, but that is not yet confirmed). Next I will try to use a process of elimination to see which factor was causing the poor performance and will report back when I have worked it out.
DG
UPDATE #2.
Well, 4 hours after turning my TREO 680 on (with phone ON), bluetooth off, and the last 2 hours with beam receive on, brightness at maximum bright, and GPRS ON, and my battery is still 99% charged! I have not made or received any calls as yet, but this is the sort of performance I was expecting when i bought this phone and I am (no longer) disappointed. DG
DG - thanks a lot for all the updates on the state of your Treo 680 battery life - like you I have been able to keep a very regular performance.
Other Treonauts considering the battery life on the Treo 680 to be too low for them should currently simply consider purchasing a spare battery.
Cheers, A.
after trying out 2 treo 680s with cingular, i have ended up returning both of them for a full refund. there are some serious software issues that prevent full use of the treos that i bought, which is disappointing, because i was in love with my 650, and have turned a lot of people on to treos. maybe after a couple months all the bugs will be worked out of the new software and i can ''come home'' to treo again.
FINAL UPDATE.
My expt is over, I tried various combinations of different features on or off over a 24 hour period, and I am pretty happy with the results. Note, these are only my findings for my TREO 680.
Bottom line (this is a summary of my findings with different modes on or off):
1. In standby mode (phone ON, Auto time check, bluetooth, IR, Email checking ALL OFF, and little/no active use), my phone loses around 0.25-0.5% battery power per hour. This fits pretty well with the rating of up to 300 hours standby time.
2. Power usage increases significantly in standby mode (Phone ON) with: Auto time checking ON, IR beam receive ON and Bluetooth ON, even with little/no active use. Each of these features seemed to contribute noticably to battery drain. Usage was between 2 and 4% battery power per hour.
3. Active use (eg. email/web/bluetooth activity and screen on for roughly 50% of the time the phone is on) drains the battery much faster, as would be expected. Usage under these conditions was between 8 and 14% per hour.
4. I think one of the most important things I did was to properly condition the battery as described by JC (entry 36) ie. FULLY discharge and recharge at least twice (without using it in between). My phone performance seemed to improve remarkably after this, although unfortunately I did not formally test it beforehand.
So, despite initial concerns on my part, I think the TREO 680 is performing as expected (for me at least). I hope this information is helpful.
Anyone know if PALM is doing anything about this? I mean why should we be doing "tweaks" at all to get more battery life. I never worried about charging my 650. Now I'm alwasy glancig at my battery meter. I work long hours some days and do not have time or acess to charge my phone. This is unacceptable.
UPDATE: The spare 1200mAh battery for your Treo 680 is now finally available in the Treonauts Accessories Shop.
http://shop.treonauts.com/content/accessories/8-37--1346.htm
Cheers, A.
Sedio has an extended battery for the 680 but that battery is 2400 mAh and makes the device look like it's pregnant. http://www.seidioonline.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=598

